Matilda Told Such Dreadful Lies

Recently, I sent my friend Alex a copy of a book I love, Lucy Sussex’s Matilda Told Such Dreadful Lies. She hasn’t read the book yet, but she has given me permission to put up an edited version of the letter that accompanied it, because she knows how much I love this book. Alex also knows how I want everyone on the planet to buy and read this book.

On that note, have the links for Amazon and Book Depository. Unfortunately, Ticonderoga Publications have not as yet released an e-book (though I’m told they are working on it). For the record, I don’t use affiliate links, but Russell once gave me $10 off the books I was buying because apparently if I stand up in front of a room full of fellow geeks drunk I will yell “if you don’t buy this books you’re a fucking moron”. And then people will by the book.  So that’s full disclosure for y’all.

Cover of Matilda Told Such Dreadful Lies

Spoiler, not actually Matilda pictured. Probably.

The Letter

Dear Alex,

I feel like this is a personal gift, but it probably requires explanation and bonus probably-over-the-top review to explain why I love it so much. I am assuming you have not read this story or any of Sussex’s other work, but she is published internationally and I could be completely wrong. Laugh at me if this is the case.

Lucy Sussex is my favourite Australian writer for one reason: the story “The Queen of Erewhon”.

But back to “The Queen of Erewhon” and it’s importance to me. I read this story when I was around 13. It was in some Best SF Of The Year collection my grandparents had gotten me for Christmas. The collection as a whole was quite dull, the usual uninspiring, uninteresting cheap short story tricks that were driving me mad and getting me kicked out of English Lit classes and put me off attempts to “analyse” prose for a good few years.

That last story in the book, though. Right at the back. This story about these women’s lives and the tragedy of Erewhon, it… fucking haunted me. When I eventually reached it, I read it over and over and, unusually for short stories (where previously I found them useless and empty), I couldn’t stop thinking about it. Weird looks from the friends I was brave enough to show it to.

The story was eye-opening, a beautiful post-ozone-layer post-climate-change dystopia, brimming with history and layers and richness and such a strong fabric of a tiny community, its cultures and its world.

It was my introduction to the fact that lesbians and lesbianism were a real thing, not just an insult yelled at you from cars as you walked home. It was something real and something that could be okay. The story covers the whole spectrum, in hindsight, also introducing me to ideas of polyamory, bisexuality and thoughts I wouldn’t understand till a decade later. Can you tell this story hypnotised me and stayed with me a bit? I think it’s a rare gift of a short story to manage such a thing. Especially in a 13 year old.

Even if you don’t read the rest, or read only some of this book and hate it, please make sure that you read this story and consider that my gift. I will be shocked if you hate it or can’t understand why I love it so much.

Okay, I have tried to explain my feelings and the importance of this story to me so many times now. I think I might be in love with this story a bit. I want it to be seen more, and wow do I want friends to have opinions on it.

The Actual Review of the Rest of the Book

Continue reading

The Worst Book Cover I Have Ever Seen

I read an excellent book recently.

Unfortunately it also has the misfortune of what is pretty close to the worst cover I have ever seen. I’ve owned it for quite a few months now and I still can’t get past just how dreadful it is.

Trying to convince people this book is fucking fantastic is going to be a challenge. But it is.

Trying to convince people this book is fucking fantastic is going to be a challenge. But it is.

Fools is the most genuine examination of identity within the cyberpunk framework that I have ever read. Pat Cadigan has created a very rich world with enough allegories and metaphors that are painfully pointed or sometimes very beautiful. These are layered neatly with literal interpretations, an exploration of the physical consequences of the ability to create false personalities and memories within the brain, all loaded into an excellent action-adventure full of all sorts of fun. It’s not what you’d call dry.

I don’t feel like I’m doing this book justice in that description.

For context I read Fools directly after Slow River by Nicola Griffith and they make for an interesting comparison. I’m not going to go into detail, but these two books exemplify to me what this idea of bio-punk SHOULD be about rather than letting it be led by Paolo Bacigalupi and that fucking awful embarrassment of a book The Windup Girl.

However, moving back to Cadigan, the reason I picked up Fools was I’d just read Synners and this was the only other book of Cadigan’s that I could easily find. For some reason, only one of her books has been put into the Gollancz SF Masterworks, which is a shame, because I think both these books are worthy of it. Book depository tells me Cadigan has an SF gateway omnibus collection featuring Fools, Mindplayers and Tea From An Empty Cup coming out in about four months. It’s basically moved to the top of my ‘to buy’ list.

See a much prettier cover.

See a much prettier cover.

Synners is very much the product of that old-skool cyberpunk period when Cadigan was roped into being the token girl in the boys’ club. Of all the cyberpunk (not much) I have read it does something the other books never managed: it makes the drive for technological post-humanism that all the characters have seem human, humane and relatable. Suddenly, you find yourself able to understand this desire and force, as well as the fun of a tech-ridden world. It doesn’t make hacking into a cool but unintelligible and mysterious dark art – it treats it as a skill and a mindset. It makes them relatable and learnable.

Cadigan fills the book with powerful imagery and concepts, and while some of the repeating phrases are clumsy and a little corny, the themes are kept grounded enough. On top of that, there’s an awareness of the socio-economic consequences that isn’t glossed over, which I think makes it feel more honest. It really hit me writing this. Synners is the book that has made cyberpunk seem like a sub-genre of value to me for more than just it’s hilarious and fun aesthetic (which I love to bits).

Both books are excellent, but Synners is probably an easier book to love. That said, both of these books have aged well, especially in comparison to many of the other cyberpunk novels of that generation. Definitely worth reading.

It’s a shame most of her books don’t seem to be as easily available as Synners.

Episode 21 “The Green”

In another step in getting the podcast back on track, we have another episode of How I Got My Boyfriend To Read Comics up! While there was a delay in publication, to make up for it, we even have the return of the podcast notes!

 How I Got My Boyfriend To Read Comics (tiny)

Welcome to the eco hippy Green version of the podcast notes:

The News

  •  Transgender character in Batgirl finally after a few months of build up. Seems to be handled well.
  •  The greatest comics based website to exist ever: http://hasdcdonesomethingstupidtoday.com/
  •  Demon Knights and Dial H for Hero cancelled. Sadness.
  • There is a DC version of Scribblenauts coming out Supposedly every DC character ever. Actual footage of Steph Brown has been seen! (via Kotaku)
  • Seeing more info and pics on Arkham Origins are coming online. Have yet to see any chicks. Lots of Deathstroke and Deadshot. (via VG24/7)

What We’ve Been Reading

Zoe

  • Among Others by Jo Walton (also known as the worst book ever written)
  • Meredith Gran books based on her webcomics
  • The Scarlet Rider by Lucy Sussex
  • Content for Gender through Comics online course
  • Demon Knights.
  • Played loads of Tomb Raider (or as I keep calling it, Lara Croft)

Chris

  • Roadside Picnic by  Arkady and Boris Strugatsky
  • Habitation of the Blessed by Cat Valente

The Green (or the topic of the week)

We wanted to explore the idea of “the Green” in the Vertigo/DCU universes. We decided to use a comparison between Poison Ivy against Alan Moore’s classic take on Swamp Thing. While we discuss the gender issues, the differences to nu52 and constantly confuse the title of Cast Shadows (the Poison Ivy trade discussed).

Feedback

As always you can send us feedback in several ways. Leave a message on this blog post or on the Facebook page. You can also tweet to @thewolverina or email feedback@wolverina.net. If you enjoyed listening, you can even leave a comment on our iTunes page. You can also receive notifications for all our podcast updates via RSS on the How I Got My Boyfriend To Read Comics homepage.

Women’s Week.

Another post from ages ago!

I’m still in contact with the science fiction club at the nearby university where I studied. Mostly, I’m friends with the older kids who will be graduating soon. Occasionally, I get dragged out of the grumpy old-guard box, dusted off and asked to help them out with something. This time around it was their Women’s Week celebration stall. They wanted to be able to recommend books pointing out that SF&F isn’t quite as alienating and misogynistic as it seems when your exposure is Game of Thrones, and The Avengers movie. This is a cause I can get right behind, so I agreed to turn up to provide stickers and a recommendations  list of awesome books and comics about and by women.

At the stall itself showing my usual charm and winning personality to the young ones.

At the stall itself showing my usual charm and winning personality to the young ones. Photo taken by my housemate.

Of course, I left it to the last minute, so the lists are rather rushed.

Speculative Fiction Books:

  • The Left Hand of Darkness by Ursula Le Guin
  • Cards of Grief by Jane Yolen
  • The Ladies of Mandrigyn by Barbara Hambly
  • The Speed of Dark by Elizabeth Moon
  • Palimpsest by Cat Valente
  • Frankenstein by Mary Shelley
  • The Time Traveler’s Wife by Audrey Niffenegger
  • The Female Man by Joanna Russ
  • Dreamsnake by Vonda McIntyre.
  • Boneshaker by Cherie Priest
  • Nylon Angel by Marianne De Pierres
  • Synners by Pat Cadigan
  • To Say Nothing of the Dog by Connie Willis
  • The Mists of Avalon by Marion Zimmer Bradley
  • Shards of Honor by Lois McMaster Bujold
  • Grass by Sheri Tepper
  • Where Late the Sweet Birds Sang by Kate Wilhelm
  • Mappa Mundi by Justina Robertson
  • Dawn (Lilith’s Brood #1) by Octavia Butler
  • The Snow Queen by Joan Vinge
  • The Forgotten Beasts of Eld by Patricia McKillip

Comic Books (individual trades):

  • Fun Home by Alison Bechdel
  • Captain Marvel: In Pursuit of Flight by Kelly Sue Deconnick
  • Womanthology: Heroic (by various, organised by Renae De Liz)
  • Friends with Boys by Faith Erin Hicks
  • Hopeless Savages by Jen Van Meter
  • Wonder Woman: The Circle by Gail Simone

Comic Book Series

  • Birds of Prey v1 by Gail Simone, DC
  • Powergirl by Jimmy Palmiotti, Justin Grey and Amanda Conner, DC
  • Madame Xanadu by Matt Wagner and Amy Reeder Hadley, Vertigo
  • X-23 by Majorie Liu, Marvel

I did try for a variety of sub-genres and both explicitly and implicitly feminist books. I keep looking at it thinking it needs improvements, I mean it’s pretty much all white straight women, with a bend towards fantasy.

I’m not entirely comfortable with that.

My weak rationalisations: I was limited by trying to go for the ‘oh yeah, I’ve heard that mentioned before’ effect (especially in nerds) but not for a lot of super obvious stuff like J.K. Rowling. I also wanted to limit the amount of YA, going instead for 80s/90s books that have a younger audience, but predate the idea of the YA genre as defined by marketing. I’m also avoiding short stories, which takes away a lot of awesome stuff I’ve been reading. Uni students, even the SF and geeky ones around here, aren’t exactly the most well-read of creatures. I’d like to think it’s because they are too busy studying, but well… I can remember being a uni student.

Anyway, there’s a definite need for improvement. Hopefully if I’m asked again next year, I’ll be able to come up with something better. If nothing else, I’ll be more organised.

Suggestions for next time welcome! I’ll probably still be in contact with a few of the kids next year!

Swancon: After Buffy

So Swancon! That science fiction convention I was on the committee on and helped run.
Have a picture taken by Arinellen from the XXP bloggers shows my approach to event management.

I was pretty worn out at this point.

I was pretty worn out at this point.

I ran one panel at Swancon this year, leading the feral group I call my ‘craft day’ friends: Penny, Nic, Emma and Sarah F. Sadly, I didn’t think to grab pictures of this set up. Basically, these are friends from a few years back, when I decided I wanted to start up an informal crafting meet-up at my house every couple of weeks. These are the friends that kept showing up, even though we very quickly stopped crafting and just started watching tv, arguing and recommending other media to each other.

The panel After Buffy, was an attempt at moving past the main few action women in the modern consciousness. When people talk about awesome women, strong women, and female action heroes, what you quickly notice is that Buffy, Ripley, Sarah Connor and Lara Croft are the names that keep coming up and dominating the conversation with their various merits rather than diversifying the list. It becomes a battle for perfection, rather than finding loads of role models.

I promised we’d put a list of the recommendations online as we didn’t get time to mention many of the creators and texts that we wanted. These aren’t all SF or action, but whatever we thought had the potential to showcase women being awesome, whether the work itself was terrible or brilliant. They are things we’ve recommended to each other, discussed loads or watched in a group.

TV and Movies
Cliff Chiang's take on The Runaways.

Cliff Chiang’s take on The Runaways.

  • Xena
  • Lost Girl
  • Birds of Prey
  • Rizzoli & Isles
  • Hope Springs
  • The Runaways (the movie)
  • But I’m A Cheerleader
  • Kamikaze Girls
  • Tank Girl
  • Daria
  • Itty Bitty Titty Committee
  • Middleman
  • Brave
  • Tangled
Books and Authors
  • Barbara Hambly
  • Jane Yolen
  • Ursula Le Guin
  • Joanna Russ
  • Lucy Sussex
  • Cherie Priest
  • Cat Valente
  • Vonda N. McIntyre
  • Marianne De Pierres
  • L. Frank Baum, The Wonderful Wizard of Oz
  • Gael Baudino, Gossamer Axe
  • Genevieve Valentine, Mechanique
Comics
Not actually sure who drew this Painkiller Jane. She is amazing.

Not actually sure who drew this Painkiller Jane. She is amazing.

  • Gail Simone
  • Alison Bechdel
  • Jen Van Meter
  • Faith Erin Hicks
  • Wonder Woman (Greg Rucka, Gail Simone)
  • ’92/93 Black Canary (Sarah Byam)
  • Queen & Country (Greg Rucka)
  • Painkiller Jane (Jimmy Palmiotti)
  • Digger (Ursula Vernon)
  • Passage of Time
  • Catwoman (Ed Brubaker)
  • Powergirl (Jimmy Palmiotti, Justin Gray, Amanda Connor)
  • Manhunter (Marc Andreyko)
  • X-23 (Marjorie Liu)
  • Captain Marvel (Kelly Sue DeConnick)
  • Persepolis (Marjane Satrapi)

The panel itself went really well. Surprisingly well. We came third in the best-in-program contest which is pretty wicked, and we weren’t expecting the crowd we got. We were also impressed that we managed to only upset one person (we’re really sorry, Kendra!) with how opinionated and overboard we tend to go. The vibe was really good too. It was the most fun I’ve ever had at a panel, and the impression I’ve gotten is many people felt the same. The vibe continued into the next panel (on queer representation) with the recommending spirit continuing onwards.

The audience was pretty awesome. At the time, we weren’t expecting such an awesome discussion from the audience, or the number of people that showed up. We’ve managed to get most of the notes (borrowing heavily from alias_sqbr for this post). Note: I don’t necessarily agree with a lot of these recs and I can’t guareentee we didn’t miss a whole heap.

batwomanreeder

Amy Reeder’s take on Batwoman

  • My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic
  • Batwoman
  • The Legend of Korra
  • Girls with Slingshots
  • Questionable Content
  • The Princess Diaries series (especially 2)
  • Tank Girl
  • Girl Genius
  • Ash
  • Fables
  • Batgirl
  • Ice Princess
  • Global Frequency
  • Runaways (the comic)

I did notice a fixation on the princess tropes and roles that subvert or bring in alternative roles. Personally I think the princess trope just needs to be burned to the ground and erased from the media’s collective consciousness alongside Barbie and cheerleaders (even subverted ones like Buffy). However, the panel and certainly members of the audience disagreed with me and there was no shortage of suggestions. I still wonder if the reason we defend these princesses is that we have so few other characters to form attachments to.

Possible idea for a future panel? One not run by me, I’ve sworn I’m out after this round.

Full credit needs to go to Lily for pointing out that we completely missed Batwoman. She won a signed copy of Boneshaker by Cherie Priest – while there were millions of good suggestions from the audience, this was the most obvious character and comic we missed.

We’re always after suggestions, and people should feel free to keep mentioning stuff in the comments.

Ain’t dead.

You might have noticed wolverina.net has been a little quiet the past few months. Traveling and blogging was a little too much after becoming quite ill while in New York. I decided I wanted the rest of my holiday to be just a holiday.

So what has been taking up my time since returning to Perth between Weddings and Various Family Engagements.

To start with, Lego Batman 2: DC Superheros.

Lego Batman 2

I think I prefer the first Lego Batman, but I would like to review this properly when I have finished it. 100% is still a hard goal to reach when you have absolutely no skill at console gaming!

20130115-231709.jpg

My cat took a liking to my copy.

Polished off Chicks Dig Comics over the Christmas holidays. It’s fun reading, basically a series of light essays by ladies discussing an aspect of comics and the geek culture that they love. From crushes on Aquaman to adventures in growing up in Snowtown from Ellis’s Fell to Sandman fangirling to Simone’s inspiring first essay, the book keeps you amused. It’s great to see the variety of personal stories every woman uses to describe her experiences.

The book does mention the discrimination in the industry regularly, it doesn’t dominate the discussion throughout the book (which is pretty refreshing, to put it mildly). The interviews add a lot to the discussion, and I particularly loved the perspectives of Rucka and Conner.

I’m curious to see more in this series, but Timelords and Whedon fangirling aren’t really my thing. Maybe they’ll have a Batman or a computer games book soon. Or Stargate. Hmm.

My only other holiday news is that I have taken to collecting HeroClix, or at least, the DCU ladies created. My partner is laughing as I now have over 30 of them.

20130115-231805.jpg

Yes, I am a Stephanie Brown fangirl. I prefer her as Spoiler over Batgirl, but she is amazing as both.

Assuming I don’t melt from the heat in the next few days, I’m hoping to get this blog running a lot more regularly in 2013. We are in a severe heatwave here though.

New York Comic Con

I’m pretty behind on keeping this site up to date at the moment, I haven’t even gotten the show notes for Episode 19 of How I Got My Boyfriend To Read Comics up yet.

This will remain the case for the at least the next few days. I’m going to be at New York Comic Con for various parts of the next four days and will be writing articles for Comics Bulletin.

So if you really miss my ranting, you should head that way. If you want very confused irl ranting, I’m (one of?) the girl with blue hair, confused expression and an Australian accent. Or email or twitter at me. If I can find them before I leave, I have leftover podcast stickers to get rid of too.

Sticky

I keep forgetting to write about this and then feeling bad, because everyone should know about it. I really enjoyed my time in Denver, Colorado – not just because my friends had the most adorable little ginger kitten.

Sake the ginger cat, in my makeshift 'handbag'

See what I mean about cute? Also she is a little trouble maker, can you blame me from putting her in this post?

The first day I was there was a Friday, and both my friends had to work, so I spent the day lost and wandering around. I ended up near Santa Fe Road (or Avenue) in the late afternoon, checking out all the galleries.  Nearby (a block or two off the main strip) was Love Gallery, which is incredibly cool.

A shot of a wall, with a series of frames enclosing a montage of stickers

The cool set-up

It’s a tiny gallery, but one that seems to run pretty cool concepts. This month’s exhibition is called Peel’N’Stick, where everyone was invited to submit their own sticker designs. See what I mean by awesome concepts?

There was a fair amount of variety, everything from skulls and overly masculine imagery for skaters, to feminist propaganda, to anime inspired girls, to the designs a 7 year old boy sent in. Stickers from all around the world, including a girl from Australia.

Stickers, centre image red with a veiled woman

I have to admit the stickers addressing sexuality and gender were more interesting than the skateboarding ones (for me at least).

I am utterly charmed by this exhibition. I ended up buying a whole pile of the excess stickers that were for sale and it absolutely made my day.

Stick by an Australian girl in the centre

The sticker I have tried to get in the center of this photo is one by an Australian girl whose name I have forgotten.

The owner’s knowledge of all the stickers and their creators was impressive, he knew a stupid amount of detail about the stickers and the creators, and showed a real interest in every piece. Discovering the culture itself was fascinating: a community based around indie sticker creation, something I wouldn’t have thought existed, but which apparently is a thriving little sub-culture. When I arrived the gallery owner was in the middle of creating a bus-stop style chair for visitors to add the stickers to. I’m a little sad I won’t get to see what it looks like by the end of exhibition.

A just made Bus-Stop bench in the middle of being covered in stickers

When I visited it was very much a work in progress.

If you live in Denver, you should totally check it out and be prepared to grin like a loon. The show is on til the 30th of September, so you don’t have much time left.

My Comikaze experience

For the hell of it I wandered my way to LA to go to Comikaze – a new-ish comic and pop culture expo that was branded with Stan Lee this year for the first time (it has only run once before).

I had fun, for the most part. It started quite poorly with management of the lines. Seriously, I spent half an hour trying to figure out where to line up, then another hour and a half lined up outside not going anywhere in a huge-arse line – despite the fact I’d already bought a ticket. It was stupidly hot (even for an Australian) and there was no water anywhere… and loads of people with kids. So I promptly went screw this shit and went back to my hotel to read, rehydrate and grumble about it for awhile. I wandered back at about 3pm and had no worries getting in then, so that was nice, if a little frustrating. I can’t even begin to imagine how the poor sellers must have felt, dealing with such a grumpy crowd and presumably empty morning.

I’m staying in the same hotel as a few of the organisers, so I should mention that (in the hotel’s public laundry) I ended up talking to a lady involved about this issue. She commented that her company had only taken over the running of the event three months ago, and weren’t made aware of a whole pile of ticket sales. That, plus issues with the fire wardens freaking out, somewhat complicated the huge crowds and slowed their reaction time. This explains a lot about the running of the show, but probably doesn’t excuse the poor social media handling of all the problems.

As a seperate issue, the reason I’m pretty wary of conventions and geek spaces in general was out in full force. The boys that loudly judge and have somewhat offensive opinions on the various cosplayers (and other women), the boys that knock and lean into you with no apology. The usual response of being ignored or slighted for being a nerdy girl with an opinion – or being gently pressured away from the comics you are sorting through because you can’t ‘really’ be into that. Being by myself also meant I had to be good, and not punch or swear at anyone (a change in attitude that has never really suited me). This is not the fault the organisers, just the behaviour of people, exacerbated by the fact I didn’t know anyone and a poor mood after the line business.

I think perhaps I was a little too spoiled by Geek Girl Con, which was remarkable in its absence of this behaviour, as well as smaller crowds. Plus, a month of road tripping to relatively isolated areas and not really talking to anyone probably hasn’t helped.

Thankfully, not all of the convention was like this. I had a genuinely good time once I managed to tune out the annoyances. I did get angry enough to take a snapshot of some of the especially offensive fanart around though. Cheesecake worries me a hell of a lot less, even in excess, than this thoughtless bullshit.

bad shot of a fan art stall, with dodgey art.

Superheroes in everyday situations! So obviously Wonder Woman goes in the kitchen, hilarious right?!? Superman was in a bathroom and Batman in some sort of library or office.

I got to meet the lovely and amazing Eliza Frye. I absolutely love her work. I came to it through Kickstarter when I put money towards Regalia, a book she wrote and drew. It was such a beautiful and surreal collection of ponderings on sexuality and love, I read it over a year ago and it still comes back and haunts me. As a result, I have four of her prints on my loungeroom wall and may have bought more on this occasion (as well as more of her postcards because damn, people love those). I freaked out my workplace by using her pictures as desktop backgrounds too. Some day, I will have to write a more detailed review. But yes, check out her stuff and know that she is awesome in person.

There were some very cool comic book collectors’ stalls. I picked up an obscene number of 90s Superboy, Green Arrow II, early Birds of Prey and vol. 1 Catwoman comics for US$1 each. It is probably going to cost me double the amount I paid for them to send those home.

I also got to meet the lovely @tarastrong who has been involved in pretty much every animated TV show I care about (including voicing Raven in Teen Titans, Babs in Batman:TAS, and Harley in Arkham City). This was mostly me being an awesome ‘aunt’ and housemate to my teenage half-step-defacto Nephew, who is a massive brony which is adorable, so I got him a signed and personalised picture.

Meeting the @Superherologist and getting a chance to buy his book Batman and Psychology was pretty cool as well. I missed his panel though, due to the line issue at the beginning of the expo, so I was pretty pissed about that. Still, he said to tweet him my thoughts, which was pretty brave!

Nightwing, old and new! I am the best fangirl. >_>

I also found two new Nightwing shirts! They’re still just in men’s cuts (which really tend to fit me a little oddly) but this means I now have three Nightwing shirts! Including one of the new Nightwing, which doesn’t actually look too bad on me.

A terrible photo of the Womanthology panel.

The Womanthology panel was excellent. I love this project and the discussion it brings, even if I get frustrated at times with the Whedon worship. I was blown away by how well Barbara Kesel handles an audience, she was unbelievably quick and witty. Nicole Sixx, who I’d seen around on the internet before, also impressed me quite a lot with her thoughts. I managed to get most of the girls’ signatures, but unfortunately I was an idiot after GGC and sent my Womanthology sketchbook back to Australia. Instead, I got a page signed in my notebook, which I will probably glue into the book when I get home.

I have to add that it was amazing how, despite the gender ratio not actually being that different in the Womanthology room, the atmosphere was completely different. It was easily the most fun I had, and I was able to relax and socialise so much more easily than I had been able to for the rest of the convention, which was pretty sweet. I hope this project continues to provide that space, inspire girls and encourage nerdy men to show that more thoughtful side of their nature.

All and all, an interesting experience and good warm up for New York Comic Con.

Black Lightning: Year One

Black Lightning

Fair warning, I’m writing this review from memory, as I’ve sent all my books back to Australia. I’m also in a loud cafe filled with hipsters and old people. I know this book has been out for years, but it’s in my head after GeekGirlCon because I re-read it before sending it back to Australia.

So, Black Lightning: Year One. I think it’s one of the first (of the very few) books by Jen Van Meter that I’ve read. I’ll apologise in advance for not even mentioning the art – Cully Hammer does a very good job but that isn’t what grabbed me at all about this book.

The trade starts on a very strong note. The first issue is powerful: instead of focusing on the origins and how the hero gains his powers, Van Meter instead focuses on themes of returning home, righting wrongs, and the frustration Jefferson Pierce feels as he looks at the neglect of “Suicide Slums”. She conveys the guilt and helplessness Jefferson feels through his stories about leaving the Slums as he goes on to his scholarships and career. She describes the creation of a hero in a relatively understated way, rather than an overblown biopic on how a young dude gets bitten by a spider. This is the story of a grown up man who has found his way, worked out how to fight and overcome the systemic battles others still face. It’s refreshing from that perspective.

The second issue was so hard hitting, I maybe had a bit of a cry. The scenes where Clark Kent visits the Garfield High School, the blunt, matter-of-fact responses to the poverty within the community, and the differences in outlook – Superman’s perceived helplessness in the face of such is a heartbreaking metaphor.

Clark Kent interviewing Pierce.

Unfortunately, the mysteries around the 100 Gang that are trying to destroy Pierce and his school quickly reveal themselves to be both supernatural and standard comic book silliness. As the plot ‘thickens’ to reveal the mysterious sources behind the gang’s power, and the major villain is realised, the themes are neglected in favour of a conspiracy and mystery adventure that is more about proving Black Lightning’s relevance and place in the DCU than anything else.

Maybe Van Meter was trying to connect Black Lightning into the wider DC universe, but it felt almost a cop-out. Perhaps it was a way to gain a more definite resolution: the trouble with the sort of realistic and complicated issues that the comic touches on, I suspect, is that there is no way to bring them to a satisfying conclusion that fully engages these themes. Instead, we bring in the supervillain with his secret cult and master plan. Out come the typical betrayer and epic battle tropes. This isn’t to say it isn’t done well and with respect to the setup created, but it is quite clumsy and shoehorned in comparison, and leaves the whole piece feeling hurried.

Clark questions the teaching methods for dealing with student strippers.

This for me is the comic at it’s strongest. Questioning how school and superheroes can possibly be relate to students who work after school as strippers.

I’m sounding pretty harsh, which I don’t mean to be. Certainly, while it is a flawed trade, the problems aren’t around Meter’s handling of race and life in low socio-economic areas. They instead come from the plot following comic-book tropes which, really, is a pretty minor issue to have with a book firmly placed in the superhero pulp genre.

From memory, these Year One stories were an attempt at giving lesser known characters cohesive origin stories and exposure. I’d say Black Lightning: Year One does a pretty good job of that aim on top of how it delves into the issues around Garfield High School. Definitely worth buying.